How Data Can Save Your Team (Without Resentment)

Mar 12

If you’re managing a struggling team, I bet you know what they don’t want.

More data tracking.

Your staff already track a million things—medications, timecards, progress notes, health data, incident reports, and probably how many times the copier jams in one day. (Spoiler: It’s always too many.)

So the idea of adding more tracking? Yeah, that’ll go over about as well as announcing mandatory overtime before a holiday weekend.

But here’s the kicker: What gets tracked, gets done.

And struggling teams? They’re often tracking the wrong things.

The Problem: Tracking Compliance Instead of Success

Most IDD provider agencies track compliance—whether meds were given, logs were completed, or staff showed up on time. Important? Absolutely. But does it actually make the work environment better? Not really.

The teams that thrive aren’t just tracking check-the-box compliance. They’re tracking leading measures—the behaviors that drive success.

Think of it like saving money. If all you track is your bank account balance, you’re just watching numbers fluctuate and hoping for the best. But if you track how often you pack lunch instead of eating out or how many times you skip that impulse Amazon purchase, suddenly, you’re influencing the outcome.

The same logic applies to managing people.

Step 1: Supervisors, Track THEIR Behavior First

Let’s talk about Paul. Paul is a frontline supervisor. Paul is frustrated because his staff aren’t engaged. They complain, they quit, they don’t seem to care.

Paul is tracking their performance, but is Paul tracking his own?

Probably not.

And as a leader in your organization, your job is to help supervisors track the right things—not just hold them accountable for their teams’ performance, but ensure they’re measuring their own impact.

Here’s a trick: What if Paul started tracking just one thing—whether he follows up on the concerns his staff bring to him?

✅ Did I check in with Sarah after she asked for more training?
✅ Did I follow up with Andre after he said his workload was too high?
✅ Did I remember to praise Samantha for handling that tough situation so well?

Paul starts self-tracking. And something amazing happens.

It turns out, he was listening to his team—but he wasn’t following through. Once he started holding himself accountable, his team felt heard, and engagement improved.

That’s the power of self-monitoring + feedback in action. And as a higher-level leader, if you want stronger teams, you have to make sure your supervisors are tracking their own follow-through—not just reporting on their staff’s mistakes.

Step 2: Give DSPs Something Worth Tracking

Right now, your DSPs track compliance data because they have to. But what if they started tracking behaviors that actually made their job better?

Examples:

Instead of just tracking time punches, they track their own wins—like initiating a fun outing or playing a favorite game with an individual.
Instead of just checking off trainings, they track their progress toward credentialing—like a personal scoreboard.
Instead of just having the payroll system tracking call-offs, they self-report call-offs (because people are surprisingly motivated when they see their own data).

When staff track and report their own behaviors, they become more invested in doing the right things. It’s the difference between being micromanaged and taking ownership.

Why This Works (Science + Common Sense)

This isn’t just feel-good theory—it’s backed by behavioral science and well-documented in workplace studies.

🔹 Self-tracking increases behavior automatically. Research published in the Journal of Organizational Behavior Management shows that when employees monitor their own behavior, they naturally improve performance—even without extra incentives. It’s why fitness trackers work—suddenly, you want to take the stairs.

🔹 Tracking behavior creates a feedback loop. But here’s the catch—data alone isn’t enough. If tracking doesn’t come with some kind of feedback, it fizzles. That feedback could be from a supervisor, a leaderboard, or even just self-reflection. (For those interested in the deeper science behind this, check out the Association for Behavior Analysis International).

🔹 It shifts focus from catching bad behavior to reinforcing good behavior. Instead of constantly correcting staff, you’re creating a culture where the right actions are noticed and rewarded. And agencies that invest in positive reinforcement strategies see measurable improvements in retention and engagement (Aubrey Daniels International).

How to Implement This Without Annoying Everyone

1️⃣ Keep it stupid simple. One checklist item per person.

Supervisors track follow-through with staff.
DSPs track a small daily success—one thing they did well.

2️⃣ Make it part of the routine. No extra paperwork. No new software logins. Just a small addition to what’s already being done.

3️⃣ Gamify it.

Create a training progress leaderboard (friendly competition works).
Give staff a monthly shout-out for tracking their own wins.
Let supervisors use a simple yes/no checklist to see their own follow-through patterns.

The Big Takeaway

Tracking isn’t about control—it’s about clarity.

And the right kind of tracking doesn’t feel like micromanagement—it feels empowering.

So if your team is struggling, here’s your action step as a leader: Pick one key behavior and start tracking it with feedback.

You’ll be amazed at how fast things turn around.

Want More Smart Ways to Retain DSPs?

If this post hit home, you’ll love our weekly podcast on managing people smarter. Check out our latest episode or sign up for our email list (below) to get practical, no-fluff insights straight to your inbox.